Home Divorce Lawyer How Infidelity Impacts Divorce Settlements

How Infidelity Impacts Divorce Settlements

How Infidelity Impacts Divorce Settlements

Cheating brings immense hurt, betrayal, and damage to any marriage. When divorce inevitably follows, emotions run high on both sides. Along with the emotional turmoil comes practical considerations like dividing assets and determining child custody arrangements. A lingering question for the betrayed spouse is – does the other party’s infidelity impact the financial settlement in a divorce case?

In this comprehensive guide, we explore how proof of adultery affects divorce proceedings and negotiations. We’ll breakdown the legal technicalities and precedent set by previous court rulings. Real-life examples bring the complex issues to light in a straightforward manner.

Establishing Fault in a No-Fault Divorce System

The United States has a “no-fault” divorce system where splitting spouses can dissolve their union citing “irreconcilable differences” without having to prove wrongdoing by either party. However, fault-based factors like adultery are still relevant even in a no-fault regime when it comes to determining financial settlements.

Legally speaking, “fault” in a divorce refers to misconduct that caused the irreparable breakdown of the marriage, such as adultery, physical/emotional abuse, substance abuse, or abandonment. While “no-fault” divorces don’t require assigning blame, judges maintain discretion to consider fault when examining factors like:

  • Duration of the marriage and each spouse’s respective financial contributions over time
  • Standard of living experienced and future ability to maintain it independently
  • Earning capacity and employability of each individual
  • Child custody arrangements and amount of child/spousal support needed

Proof of infidelity demonstrates one party’s failure to uphold their marital vows and responsibilities. So judges are likely to weigh fault considerations when assessing the aforementioned factors, especially in lengthy marriages with a dependent spouse.

Direct Impacts on Property Division

Dividing up jointly and separately owned property is a major aspect of any divorce settlement. Marital misconduct, especially prolonged extramarital affairs, has the potential to directly impact how assets are divided between the divorcing parties.

For example, courts may issue larger percentages of the total marital estate to the betrayed spouse as a means to compensate for the other’s breach of trust and fidelity. Case law demonstrates judges ruling the adulterous spouse forfeited equitable rights to a 50-50 split due to their unfaithful actions destroying the marriage.

ALSO READ:  How to Choose a Flat Rate Uncontested Divorce Lawyer

Fault also enables courts to consider awarding the marital home solely to the innocent party rather than forcing its sale. Long-term infidelity increases the odds of the betrayed spouse retaining key assets like the family residence containing memories. Any property or monetary gifts received during the extramarital relationship may also be excluded from the marital pot.

Alimony & Child Support Amounts Affected

Extramarital affairs factor heavily into determinations of spousal support (alimony) and child support. The rationale is the unfaithful spouse’s behavior disadvantaged their family financially and otherwise. Some impacts on these ongoing post-divorce payments include:

  • Higher monthly alimony awards to provide greater compensation for the betrayal and help cushion lifestyle changes
  • Longer payment duration of alimony since fault delays self-sufficiency of the betrayed spouse affected by the adultery
  • Higher child support amounts to account for expenses of raising children alone and regaining stability in a single-parent home
  • Imputing greater income to the adulterous spouse’s earning potential despite unemployed/underemployed status at the time of divorce

infidelity establishes need and entitlement on the part of the victimized spouse. It strengthens their case for receiving superior financial relief through robust alimony/child support awards.

Settling out of Court

The vast majority of divorce cases resolve through negotiated settlements without an adversarial court hearing. Discovery of infidelity, especially while proceedings are ongoing, often alters settlement talks profoundly.

Fault impacts bargaining power dynamics and outcomes. The betrayed spouse gains leverage knowing judges are inclined towards their position due to the other’s misconduct. This encourages more generous out-of-court deals encompassing property divisions, alimony, child issues, and other disputes.

To avoid costly litigation battles and prevent judges from factoring in fault heavily, adulterous spouses usually offer superior settlement terms. They aim to reach a resolution on acceptable terms before trial. Mediation also works better when the untrustworthy party acknowledges fault and sincerely apologizes to pave the path for fair compromises.

ALSO READ:  When to Hire a Divorce Lawyer Even If You Agree on Everything

Fault Mitigating Factors

While adultery usually damages the at-fault spouse’s case, there are some circumstances where its negative impacts may be lessened:

Isolated incident vs prolonged multiple affairs – Courts view a single lapse in judgment differently than a pattern of deceit.

Mutual indiscretions – If both spouses behaved unfaithfully, judges are less inclined to punish one party alone due to shared blame.

Distant past actions rather than current misconduct – Old infidelities carrying less ongoing influence over the marriage are given less credence.

Lack of children/brief marriage – Fault matters less for short-term childless unions with minimal shared assets at stake.

Proving provocation or consent – Rarely, the straying spouse may establish their partner’s ill treatment or open relationship instigated the extramarital relationship.

The presence of such mitigating factors, especially consent or lack of children, diminishes the ability to solely blame one party. As such, courts aim for equitable rather than punitive resolutions focusing beyond fault assignments alone.

Real Examples of Fault Impacts

To better comprehend fault’s practical effects, consider these real-life divorce cases where infidelity was a central issue:

A 15-year marriage ended with the wife awarded 60% of assets and sizeable alimony after proving her husband had a 5-year ongoing extramarital affair.

A broker earning $250K annually had to pay $100K in lump sum alimony and $5K in monthly support for 5 years to his SAHM spouse of 20 years due to his recent affairs.

A father caught cheating lost primary custody of two kids and pays 30% of income in child support versus the standard 25% guideline.

A family home was transferred entirely to the innocent wife whose 13-year marriage dissolved following her husband flaunting his mistress openly.

These outcomes clearly reflect how proof of long-term duplicity severely punished the untrustworthy spouses financially and otherwise, prioritizing suitable remedies for their former partners.

Does It Pay to Hide Affairs?

With so much at stake, the temptation grows for cheaters facing divorce to conceal their infidelities completely or minimize damage through denial. However, truth has a resilient way of surfacing regardless of deception attempts, whether through private investigations, electronic device seizures, or trickle-truth disclosures over time.

ALSO READ:  What to Do When Abused by Your Spouse

Cover-ups backfire in divorce proceedings more often than not. Judges view proven lies with grave contempt that harms the deceitful party’s credibility. It suggests conscience lacking and risks of ongoing deception. Discovery of hidden facts can also lead to courts imposing additional sanctions and awarding the aggrieved spouse their legal fees which are otherwise uncommon.

Honesty fosters the most constructive resolutions. While coming clean does not absolve fault, it indicates accountability and willingness to accept natural consequences.

Full disclosure receives more lenient treatment than lies and omissions that transform the process into a punitive experience through additional legal penalties. The betrayed spouse also suffers less uncertainty from ongoing cover-up stress.

Redemption is always possible through sincere contrition and amendable actions over time. But hiding misdeeds damages any prospects for reconciliation and poisons an already toxic divorce even further.

Truth and transparency, no matter how painful, remain the wisest approach when one must accept responsibility for their actions and see a marriage dissolve with dignity intact on all sides.

Wrapping Up

To summarize, infidelity undeniably factors into divorce financial dealings due to the harm caused despite no-fault laws. Its direct and indirect impacts range from property divisions favoring innocent spouses to enhanced alimony/child support awards providing healing support.

The degree depends on the level of betrayal evidenced along with any mitigating circumstances. Out-of-court settlements similarly reflect fault effects through pragmatic alterations.

While cheating grants no free passes, honesty navigates the difficult aftermath with more constructive resolution potential. By understanding extramarital affairs’ definitive role in property divisions and long-term support obligations, divorcing individuals make fully informed choices regarding disclosure and next steps. With emotions settled, closure and fresh starts become possible for all involved through resolution via impartial justice balancing legitimate interests on both sides.

Also Read: How to Apply for Spousal Support in Ontario


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here